Landmark Supreme Court of India rulings, explained in clear, plain language.
Filter by Act / Section
Showing 15 of 20 judgments
Can a disciplinary inquiry stand when the adjudicator is the complainant's real brother?
Ku. Kiran D/o Purushottam Bhujade vs. Sudhir Shikshan Sanstha & Ors.
The Supreme Court set aside a school teacher's termination order because the Inquiry Committee was presided over by the real brother of the complainant and key witness, creating a reasonable likelihood of bias that vitiated the entire proceedings.
Can a court deny stay of conviction to co-convicts on identical evidentiary footing?
State of U.P. vs. Mohammad Azam Khan & Ors.
The Supreme Court extended the stay of conviction to co-convicts Mohammad Abdullah Azam Khan and Dr. Tazeen Fatma, holding that the High Court's selective grant of that relief only to Mohammad Azam Khan violated the parity principle under Article 14.
Can a law disqualify panchayat candidates for having more than two children?
Mangala Bhimrao Ingle vs The Additional Commissioner, Amravati Division & Ors.
The Supreme Court referred the two-child norm election disqualification precedent in Javed v. State of Haryana to a larger bench for reconsideration, holding that India's demographic changes have made population-control disqualification laws obsolete and constitutionally suspect.
Can pension be deducted from salary of retired officers appointed to State PSC?
State of Uttarakhand Thr. Chief Secretary and Others vs. M.C. Bhandari and Another
The Supreme Court upheld Regulation 7(2) of the Uttarakhand PSC Regulations, holding that deducting pension from the salary of retired government servants appointed as PSC Chairman or Member is valid and does not violate Article 14 or the equal pay for equal work doctrine.
Can absence of mandatory officials at appointment meeting void entire recruitment?
Gaurav Mehla & Ors. vs State of Haryana & Ors.
The Supreme Court held that absence of supervisory officials at the final appointment-decision meeting is a curable defect, directed the BOD to reconvene with those officials and take a fresh decision, and set aside the annulment of the appellants' decade-long service.
Can a married daughter be denied a fair price shop dealership on compassionate grounds?
Kulsum Nisha vs State of U.P. & Ors.
The Supreme Court held that excluding married daughters from the 'family' definition in the UP fair price shop dependent quota scheme violates Articles 14 and 15(1) of the Constitution, and directed allotment of the shop to the appellant.
Can a temporary-status casual labourer claim pension without being formally regularised?
Bhikhani Devi and Etc. vs Union of India and Others
The Supreme Court held that temporary-status casual labourers of the Department of Posts are entitled to pensionary benefits on superannuation even without formal regularisation, once they complete ten years of service with benefits equivalent to temporary Group D employees.
Can conversion to Islam automatically grant Backward Class Muslim community reservation status?
The Secretary to Government vs. Sameer Ahamed N. and Others
The Supreme Court dismissed the State's appeal and upheld the High Court's quashing of the Tamil Nadu G.O. that allowed converts to Islam from Hindu backward classes to be issued Backward Class Muslim community certificates, holding that conversion cannot automatically confer membership of a notified Backward Class Muslim community.
Can a contemnor appeal to a Division Bench against a Single Judge's contempt order?
Sanjay Prasad vs Madhusudan Dwivedi & Ors.
The Supreme Court held that a Special Appeal lies before a Division Bench against a Single Judge's contempt order that decides substantive rights, and referred the correctness of Ram Kishan Fauji to a larger Bench.
Can a court direct State absorption of a lecturer without impleading the State?
State of Maharashtra vs. Sudhir S/O Motiramji Hiwarkar & Ors.
The Supreme Court set aside the High Court's direction to absorb a terminated lecturer in another college because the State of Maharashtra was never formally impleaded as a necessary party in the writ proceedings.
Can compassionate or temporary appointees claim seniority over direct recruits in government service?
M. Prema vs. The State of Tamil Nadu Rep by its Secretary to the Government and Ors.
The Supreme Court held that direct recruits of the 1983 TNPSC examination rank above both special appointees and compassionate appointees in the seniority list, and inter se seniority between special and compassionate appointees is determined by date of regularisation.
Can government employers change recruitment selection rules after the process begins?
Tej Prakash Pathak & Ors. vs Rajasthan High Court & Ors.
A five-judge bench upheld K. Manjusree, ruling that eligibility criteria for placement in a select list cannot be changed after the recruitment process begins, though recruiting bodies may devise procedural steps before each stage.
Must election commissioner appointment law be tested by a five-judge Constitution Bench?
Dr. Jaya Thakur and Ors. vs Union of India and Anr.
A divided two-judge bench referred the question of the constitutional validity of the Election Commissioners Appointment Act 2023 to the Chief Justice of India for constitution of a Constitution Bench.
Can cattle fair experience satisfy a tender requirement for user charge collection?
Micky Traders vs L.R.Y. Labour Contractor & Ors.
The Supreme Court dismissed the appeals of Micky Traders and the Punjab State Agricultural Marketing Board, upholding the High Court's quashing of the bid acceptance on the ground that cattle fair experience does not satisfy the tender's requirement of experience in collecting user charges for government bodies.
Do employees have a right to promotion under rules existing when vacancies arose?
THE BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED AND ANOTHER VERSUS G.N. MANI RAVINDER AND OTHERS ETC.
The Supreme Court held that employees cannot claim a right to be considered for promotion under old, repealed rules; their eligibility is determined by the rules in force at the time of consideration.
Scroll to load more