Story
Just Compensation for a Skilled Carpenter
Supreme Court rules 100% functional disability and awards costs for a prosthetic leg, recognizing the true impact of amputation on a skilled worker's life.
Supreme Court awards 100% functional disability and cost of prosthetic leg to carpenter
The Central Legal Question
What is 'just compensation' for a skilled carpenter whose leg is amputated, making him unable to perform his trade?
Appellant's Argument
My injury has caused 100% functional disability as I can no longer work as a carpenter. I also need funds for a lifelong prosthetic leg.
What is Functional Disability?
The impact of an injury on a person's ability to perform their specific job, which can be greater than the medically assessed percentage of physical disability.
Income Reassessed
Recognized carpentry as a skilled job and increased the notional monthly income from Rs. 5,000 to Rs. 9,000.
100% Functional Disability
Held that for a carpenter, leg amputation is a 100% functional disability as he can no longer sit and work.
Prosthetic Leg Costs
Awarded Rs. 10,00,000 for the purchase, replacement, and maintenance of a prosthetic leg throughout the claimant's life.
Legal Reference
| Legal Subject | Provision Applied |
|---|---|
| Just Compensation | Motor Vehicles Act principles |
What this case means
A carpenter whose right leg was amputated after an accident was awarded enhanced compensation by the Supreme Court. The court ruled that for a skilled worker like a carpenter, this injury causes 100% functional disability. It also awarded a significant amount for the lifelong cost and maintenance of a prosthetic leg.
What the Supreme Court held
The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, reassessing the carpenter's functional disability at 100% and his notional income at a higher rate. It significantly enhanced the total compensation to Rs. 35,95,923, which included a specific amount for the lifelong cost of a prosthetic leg.
Case: SHANKAR DUTT VERSUS UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD. AND OTHERS (2026) Citation: 2026 INSC 656
Want the full legal reasoning, citations and case documents?
Read the full judgment analysis
