Story
Section 69 BNS: When Does a Failed Marriage Promise Become a Crime?
The Supreme Court clarifies that deceitful intent from the outset is essential; a promise broken due to family objection is not an offence.
Supreme Court Quashes FIR Under BNS Section 69 for Absence of Deceitful Intent
The Central Legal Question
Does failing to marry after a consensual relationship amount to deceit under Section 69 BNS?
Appellant's Argument
The relationship was consensual; no deceitful intent existed from the beginning; the promise was broken due to mother's objection, not fraud.
What is Deceitful Means (Section 69 BNS)?
A promise to marry made with no intention of fulfilling it from the outset, used to induce consent to sexual intercourse, constituting a punishable offence.
Consensual Relationship
The FIR itself showed the complainant consented without the promise of marriage being the specific basis for the first physical encounter.
No Deceitful Intent
Appellant's refusal to marry was due to mother's objection, indicating the promise was made in good faith, not as a deception.
Section 69 BNS Requires Initial Fraud
The offence under Section 69 BNS requires that the promise was made with no intention of being fulfilled from the very beginning.
Legal Reference
| Legal Subject | Provision Applied | Equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| Sexual intercourse on false promise of marriage | Section 69 BNS | Section 375 read with Section 90 IPC |
What this case means
The appellant was accused under Section 69 of the Bhartiya Nyaya Sanhita for allegedly entering into physical relations under a false promise of marriage. The Supreme Court found the relationship was consensual and no deceitful intent was established, as the appellant's refusal to marry was attributed to his mother's objection. The Court quashed the FIR, clarifying that a failed promise due to external circumstances is not punishable under Section 69 BNS.
What the Supreme Court held
The Supreme Court allowed the appeal and quashed FIR No. 11196030250292 dated 20 May 2025 registered at Sayajiganh Police Station, Vadodara City, Gujarat. The Court held that the relationship was consensual and no deceitful intent on the part of the appellant was established, as the failure to marry was attributable to his mother's objection rather than a pre-existing intent to deceive. All pending applications were also rejected.
Case: Kunal Rameshbhai Kalyani vs The State of Gujarat & Anr. (2026) Citation: 2026 INSC 987
Want the full legal reasoning, citations and case documents?
Read the full judgment analysis