Story
Remission Policies: Constitution Over Statute
The Supreme Court holds Haryana's 2002 remission policy, based on the Governor's constitutional power, prevails over the later 2008 statutory policy.
Supreme Court holds Haryana's 2002 remission policy is constitutional, cannot be superseded by 2008 statutory policy
The Central Legal Question
Can a statutory remission policy (like Haryana's 2008 policy under CrPC) supersede an earlier policy based on constitutional power (the 2002 policy under Article 161)?
Appellant's Argument
The 2002 policy is constitutional and more beneficial, and it cannot be overridden by a later statutory policy.
What is Per Incuriam?
A legal term for a court judgment that has been decided without reference to a statutory provision or a previous judgment that would have been relevant.
2002 Policy is Constitutional
Like the 1993 policy, the 2002 policy is an exercise of the Governor's power under Article 161 of the Constitution.
Constitution Prevails
A statutory policy (2008, under CrPC) cannot override a policy framed under a distinct and independent constitutional power (2002, under Art. 161).
Precedent Clarified
The Court held that the 'Raj Kumar' (2021) judgment was per incuriam as it contradicted the larger bench's reasoning in 'Jagdish' (2010).
Legal Reference
| Legal Subject | Provision Applied |
|---|---|
| Governor's Pardoning Power | Article 161, Constitution |
| Govt's Remission Power | Section 432 CrPC |
What this case means
The Supreme Court ruled that Haryana's 2002 policy for early release of life convicts is based on the Governor's constitutional power (Article 161) and was not replaced by the 2008 policy, which is based on a statute (CrPC). Therefore, eligible convicts can still seek benefits under the more liberal 2002 policy.
What the Supreme Court held
The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, ruling that the 2002 policy is constitutional and cannot be overridden by the 2008 statutory policy. The Court declared a previous co-ordinate bench judgment to the contrary as per incuriam. The State was directed to decide the appellant's remission application under the 2002 policy within four weeks.
Case: PARVEEN KUMAR@ PARVEEN CHAUHAN vs STATE OF HARYANA & ORS. (2026) Citation: 2026 INSC 667
Want the full legal reasoning, citations and case documents?
Read the full judgment analysis

