Story
Specific Performance: Readiness and Willingness are Key
Supreme Court denies relief to a buyer who failed to prove financial capacity at the right time and delayed filing the suit.
Specific performance denied for failure to prove financial readiness and for delayed suit filing
The Central Legal Question
What does a buyer need to prove to get a court order forcing a seller to complete a property sale (specific performance)?
Appellant's Argument
I was always ready and willing. I have FDRs to prove my financial capacity, and the suit was filed within the limitation period.
What is Readiness and Willingness?
A mandatory requirement for specific performance where 'readiness' means financial capacity and 'willingness' refers to the plaintiff's conduct showing intent to perform the contract.
'Readiness' Not Proved
Financial capacity must be shown for the relevant period. FDRs created years after filing suit are not sufficient proof.
'Willingness' Lacking
Introducing new conditions and not cooperating for statutory clearances showed a lack of genuine intent to perform the contract.
Delay is Fatal
Filing a suit at the very end of the limitation period, without explanation, demonstrates a lack of diligence required for this equitable relief.
Legal Reference
| Legal Subject | Provision Applied |
|---|---|
| Condition for relief | Section 16(c), Specific Relief Act, 1963 |
What this case means
A buyer sued for specific performance of a 1990 sale agreement, but the Supreme Court denied the relief. The Court found the buyer failed to prove he had the money ('readiness') at the relevant time and his significant delay in filing the suit showed a lack of genuine intent ('willingness').
What the Supreme Court held
The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, affirming the High Court's decision to deny the equitable relief of specific performance. The Court found the plaintiff had failed to prove the mandatory requirements of continuous readiness and willingness under Section 16(c) of the Specific Relief Act.
Case: MOHAMMED KHALEEL (D) THROUGH LRs & ORS. VERSUS JAYAMMA (2026) Citation: CIVIL APPEAL NO. 2187 OF 2011
Want the full legal reasoning, citations and case documents?
Read the full judgment analysis