All insights

Can a State levy a surcharge calculated on sales tax payable, without exceeding Entry 54 List II?

Seven-Judge Bench Declares Reference on Surcharge-on-Sales-Tax Academic and Infructuous

States levied a surcharge calculated as a percentage of sales tax payable by dealers with high turnovers. Dealers argued this was an unconstitutional tax-on-tax beyond Entry 54 of List II. The Seven-J

Litigation India Editorial 15 November 2026 1 min read 2026 INSC 1192

Story

Case at a glance1 / 6

Supreme Court of India

Surcharge on Sales Tax: Reference Declared Infructuous

Arjun Flour Mills v. State of Odisha & Ors. | 2026 INSC 1192

Court: Supreme Court of India, Seven-Judge Constitution BenchDate: 04 November 2026Bench: CJI Surya Kant with Justices Bhatti, Bagchi, Anjaria, Palli, Mohana, ViswanathanArea of law: Constitutional law — State legislative competence to levy surcharge on sales tax
A reference that no longer reflects a live conflict must be declared infructuous.
Seven-Judge Bench Declares Reference on Surcharge-on-Sales-Tax Academic and Infructuous · 2026 INSC 11922026-11-15T16:38:44.138340+00:00
The legal question2 / 6

Is a Surcharge Computed on Sales Tax a Forbidden Tax-on-Tax?

The core constitutional question referred to the Seven-Judge Bench

  • Appellant: Surcharge measured by tax payable, not turnover, is not a tax on sale of goods under Entry 54 List II.
  • Appellant: India Cement (Seven-Judge Bench) holds a levy measured by another impost must be tested by what it is actually measured against.
  • Respondent States: Question is squarely covered by S. Kodar (Constitution Bench), which upheld an identical levy.
  • Respondent States: Mode of computation does not change the character; surcharge is merely an enhanced rate of sales tax.
Does computing a levy as a percentage of another tax change its constitutional character?
Seven-Judge Bench Declares Reference on Surcharge-on-Sales-Tax Academic and Infructuous · 2026 INSC 11922026-11-15T16:38:44.138340+00:00
Statutory comparison3 / 6

India Cement vs. S. Kodar: Different Fields, Different Answers

Why the perceived conflict was illusory

Legal SubjectIndia Cement Ltd. (1990) — Seven-Judge BenchS. Kodar v. State of Kerala (1974) — Constitution Bench
Levy impugnedCess on royalty under Madras Panchayats Act, 1958Additional sales tax under Tamil Nadu Additional Sales Tax Act, 1970
Relevant EntryEntries 45, 49, 50 of List II vs. Entry 54 of List I (MMDR Act)Entry 54 of List II only
Basis of invalidityOccupied field: Section 9 MMDR Act covers royalty; royalty held (incorrectly) to be a taxNo invalidity — levy upheld as enhancement of rate of sales tax
Overruled byNine-Judge Bench in Mineral Area Development Authority (2024): royalty is not a taxNever doubted by any subsequent Bench
India Cement never held that a levy measured by another tax is ipso facto unconstitutional.
Seven-Judge Bench Declares Reference on Surcharge-on-Sales-Tax Academic and Infructuous · 2026 INSC 11922026-11-15T16:38:44.138340+00:00
The Court's reasoning4 / 6

How the Court Concluded the Reference Was Infructuous

Five-step reasoning of the Seven-Judge Bench

  1. 1Step 1: Entry 54 List II gave States plenary power to tax sale/purchase of goods; taxing entry must be specific (Sundararamier).
  2. 2Step 2: Subject of tax differs from measure of tax; surcharge of 10% on 10% tax is arithmetically 1% on turnover (Bombay Tyre).
  3. 3Step 3: S. Kodar (Constitution Bench, 1974) squarely upheld an identically computed levy — that decision remains good law.
  4. 4Step 4: India Cement concerned cess on royalty under MMDR Act; it never addressed Entry 54 List II or S. Kodar.
  5. 5Step 5: Mineral Area Development Authority (Nine-Judge Bench, 2024) overruled India Cement's premise — no conflict with S. Kodar survives.
Once the foundational conflict dissolves, a reference cannot survive as a live constitutional question.
Seven-Judge Bench Declares Reference on Surcharge-on-Sales-Tax Academic and Infructuous · 2026 INSC 11922026-11-15T16:38:44.138340+00:00
The verdict5 / 6

The Verdict: Reference Rendered Infructuous

Final order of the Seven-Judge Bench

  • The Fact: Orissa and Punjab levied surcharges of 10% of sales tax payable on high-turnover dealers; both States prohibited pass-through to purchasers.
  • The Law: S. Kodar (Constitution Bench, 1974) holds such surcharges are enhancements of the rate of sales tax and valid under Entry 54 of List II; India Cement's conflicting premise is overruled by Mineral Area Development Authority (2024).
  • The Result: Reference declared infructuous; individual matters remitted to regular Benches; questions on Section 30-AA Punjab Act and Punjab Social Security Act, 2000 left open.
Reference answered as infructuous; legislative competence question governed by S. Kodar v. State of Kerala (1974).
Seven-Judge Bench Declares Reference on Surcharge-on-Sales-Tax Academic and Infructuous · 2026 INSC 11922026-11-15T16:38:44.138340+00:00
Why it matters6 / 6

What This Means for Dealers and States

Practical significance of the judgment

  • Dealers with legacy surcharge liabilities under old Orissa or Punjab sales tax cannot escape them by arguing tax-on-tax unconstitutionality.
  • A surcharge computed as a percentage of sales tax is simply a higher effective tax rate on goods sold — not a separate impermissible levy.
  • The GST reform (2017) has replaced the old sales tax regime; this ruling primarily affects past assessment disputes, not future levies.
  • Seven-Judge Benches will not be retained to answer questions already resolved by later, larger Benches — institutional resources must be preserved.
A surcharge on sales tax is not a tax on tax — it is just a higher rate of the same valid tax on goods.
Seven-Judge Bench Declares Reference on Surcharge-on-Sales-Tax Academic and Infructuous · 2026 INSC 11922026-11-15T16:38:44.138340+00:00
Seven-Judge Bench Declares Reference on Surcharge-on-Sales-Tax Academic and Infructuous — infographic summary

What this case means

States levied a surcharge calculated as a percentage of sales tax payable by dealers with high turnovers. Dealers argued this was an unconstitutional tax-on-tax beyond Entry 54 of List II. The Seven-Judge Bench held the reference was rendered academic because the perceived conflict no longer existed, and the law was already settled by the Constitution Bench in S. Kodar v. State of Kerala.

What the Supreme Court held

The Seven-Judge Bench declared the reference infructuous and academic. It held that the question of legislative competence of State Legislatures to levy the impugned surcharges is governed by S. Kodar v. State of Kerala (1974), which remains good law. The questions on Section 30-AA of the Punjab General Sales Tax Act and the constitutional validity of the Punjab Social Security Act, 2000 cess were left open for appropriate regular Benches, as were all individual contentions relating to assessments, periods of levy, and consequential reliefs.

Case: Arjun Flour Mills vs. The State of Odisha Finance Department Secretary & Ors. (2026) Citation: 2026 INSC 1192

Want the full legal reasoning, citations and case documents?

Read the full judgment analysis
Arjun Flour Mills
surcharge on sales tax
tax on tax
Entry 54 List II Seventh Schedule
legislative competence State Legislature
S. Kodar v State of Kerala
Orissa Sales Tax Act 1947
Punjab General Sales Tax Act 1948
Mineral Area Development Authority v SAIL
India Cement Ltd v State of Tamil Nadu
reference rendered infructuous
Seven Judge Bench
Article 246, Article 246A, Article 265, Article 266, Article 271, Article 141, Article 145(3), Entry 54 of List II of the Seventh Schedule, Entry 92-A of List I, Entry 54 of List I, Entry 23 of List II, Entry 50 of List II, Constitution of India
Section 5-A, Orissa Sales Tax Act, 1947