Story

What this case means
An Operational Creditor who suffered a 99.28% haircut in CIRP challenged the Successful Resolution Applicant's right to invoke arbitration on the same contract. The Supreme Court upheld the arbitration appointment but directed that the OC may raise a counterclaim solely for set-off purposes, without any positive recovery. The ruling balances the IBC's clean slate principle with equity when both parties' claims arise from the same transaction.
What the Supreme Court held
The Supreme Court upheld the Karnataka High Court's order appointing an Arbitral Tribunal. It modified the order by directing that the appellant (Modern Asset) may raise a counterclaim in the arbitration solely for the purpose of set-off against any amount found payable to the respondent, with no positive or affirmative recovery permissible on the counterclaim. The Arbitral Tribunal was also directed to consider the dispute regarding the bank guarantee encashment.
Case: Modern Asset vs KNK Construction Private Limited (2026) Citation: 2026 INSC 1103
Want the full legal reasoning, citations and case documents?
Read the full judgment analysis