All insights

Can SRA sue Operational Creditor on same contract after CIRP extinguished OC's claim?

Operational Creditor Allowed Set-Off Against SRA's Arbitration Claim After CIRP Haircut

An Operational Creditor who suffered a 99.28% haircut in CIRP challenged the Successful Resolution Applicant's right to invoke arbitration on the same contract. The Supreme Court upheld the arbitratio

Litigation India Editorial 8 October 2026 1 min read 2026 INSC 1103

Story

Case at a glance1 / 6

Supreme Court of India

Clean Slate vs. Equity: OC's Set-Off Right After CIRP Haircut

Modern Asset vs KNK Construction Pvt. Ltd. | 2026 INSC 1103

Court: Supreme Court of India | Date: 08 October 2026Bench: Justice J. B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod ChandranArea of law: Insolvency and Bankruptcy / ArbitrationOC suffered 99.28% haircut in CIRP; SRA (same promoters) then invoked arbitration on same contract
Operational Creditor Allowed Set-Off Against SRA's Arbitration Claim After CIRP Haircut · 2026 INSC 11032026-10-08T19:17:28.543146+00:00
The legal question2 / 6

Can SRA pursue arbitration against OC on same contract after CIRP extinguished OC's claim?

Core legal question decided by the Supreme Court

  • Appellant: The agreement worked itself out in CIRP; the arbitration clause is extinguished; arbitration would be a one-way street.
  • Appellant: The SRA, comprising the very erstwhile promoters, accepted the OC's claim but paid only 0.72%, and now seeks to recover from the same OC.
  • Respondent: Section 31 IBC extinguishes claims against the CD, not the CD's claims against debtors; the SRA may pursue those dues.
  • Respondent: The arbitration agreement is a separate and independent contract that survives by the doctrine of separability; all disputes should be left to the Arbitral Tribunal.
Operational Creditor Allowed Set-Off Against SRA's Arbitration Claim After CIRP Haircut · 2026 INSC 11032026-10-08T19:17:28.543146+00:00
Statutory comparison3 / 6

IBC Clean Slate: What Gets Extinguished and What Survives

Effect of Section 31, IBC 2016 on claims after resolution plan approval

Legal SubjectExtinguished by Clean SlateSurvives / Permitted
OC's claim against CD/SRAYes — settled at 0.72%, balance extinguished under Section 31(1)No further recovery against SRA
CD's claims against its debtors (OC)No — SRA may pursue these duesSRA can invoke arbitration to recover
Arbitration agreement (Clause 19.13)No — survives by doctrine of separability (Section 7, A&C Act)SRA can invoke it against OC
OC's counterclaim in arbitrationExtinguished as a recovery rightPermitted solely as set-off defence per Ujaas Energy Ltd. (2026)
The clean slate erases what others can claim against the CD — not what the CD can claim against others.
Operational Creditor Allowed Set-Off Against SRA's Arbitration Claim After CIRP Haircut · 2026 INSC 11032026-10-08T19:17:28.543146+00:00
The Court's reasoning4 / 6

How the Court Reached Its Equitable Set-Off Direction

Step-by-step reasoning of the Supreme Court

  1. 1Step 1: Confirm clean slate — Section 31(1) IBC extinguishes all pre-CIRP claims against CD and SRA not in the resolution plan.
  2. 2Step 2: Confirm arbitration survives — separability doctrine keeps Clause 19.13 alive; Section 11 review is only prima facie.
  3. 3Step 3: Confirm SRA's right — SRA may pursue CD's debts; limitation is extended by excluding moratorium under Section 60(6) IBC.
  4. 4Step 4: Identify inequity — same promoters returned as SRA, accepted OC's full claim but paid 0.72%, now seek recovery on same contract.
  5. 5Step 5: Apply Ujaas Energy Ltd. (2026) — set-off is permissible as a defence even when the counterclaim is extinguished as a recovery right.
Operational Creditor Allowed Set-Off Against SRA's Arbitration Claim After CIRP Haircut · 2026 INSC 11032026-10-08T19:17:28.543146+00:00
The verdict5 / 6

Supreme Court's Final Order

Disposal of CA @ SLP(C) No. 25068 of 2026

  • The Fact: OC suffered 99.28% haircut in CIRP; the same erstwhile promoters as SRA invoked arbitration on the identical contract.
  • The Law: Section 31(1) IBC clean slate extinguishes OC's claim against SRA; but the SRA may pursue CD's debts; arbitration agreement survives by separability.
  • The Result: Arbitral Tribunal appointment upheld; OC permitted to raise counterclaim solely for set-off — no positive recovery allowed on it.
Appellant may set off its entire original CIRP claim against any amount the Tribunal finds due to the respondent; no recovery beyond that.
Operational Creditor Allowed Set-Off Against SRA's Arbitration Claim After CIRP Haircut · 2026 INSC 11032026-10-08T19:17:28.543146+00:00
Why it matters6 / 6

What This Means for Ordinary Creditors and Businesses

Practical significance of the ruling

  • If you are an Operational Creditor in CIRP and suffered a massive haircut, the clean slate principle bars you from recovering more from the SRA.
  • But if the same SRA later sues you on the same contract, you can use your extinguished claim as a set-off shield — reducing what you owe the SRA.
  • MSME benefit allowing promoters to return as SRA does not give them an unfair advantage: equity will be considered in arbitration.
  • Resolution Professionals must diligently include all counterclaims of the CD in the Information Memorandum to avoid future inequities.
The IBC's clean slate does not let the SRA collect from a creditor while that creditor is left with nothing — set-off ensures a fair fight.
Operational Creditor Allowed Set-Off Against SRA's Arbitration Claim After CIRP Haircut · 2026 INSC 11032026-10-08T19:17:28.543146+00:00
Operational Creditor Allowed Set-Off Against SRA's Arbitration Claim After CIRP Haircut — infographic summary

What this case means

An Operational Creditor who suffered a 99.28% haircut in CIRP challenged the Successful Resolution Applicant's right to invoke arbitration on the same contract. The Supreme Court upheld the arbitration appointment but directed that the OC may raise a counterclaim solely for set-off purposes, without any positive recovery. The ruling balances the IBC's clean slate principle with equity when both parties' claims arise from the same transaction.

What the Supreme Court held

The Supreme Court upheld the Karnataka High Court's order appointing an Arbitral Tribunal. It modified the order by directing that the appellant (Modern Asset) may raise a counterclaim in the arbitration solely for the purpose of set-off against any amount found payable to the respondent, with no positive or affirmative recovery permissible on the counterclaim. The Arbitral Tribunal was also directed to consider the dispute regarding the bank guarantee encashment.

Case: Modern Asset vs KNK Construction Private Limited (2026) Citation: 2026 INSC 1103

Want the full legal reasoning, citations and case documents?

Read the full judgment analysis
Modern Asset
KNK Construction
IBC clean slate principle
CIRP
Operational Creditor
Successful Resolution Applicant
set-off counterclaim
MSME Section 240A
Section 31 IBC
arbitration agreement separability
haircut resolution plan
Section 11 Arbitration
Section 3(6), Section 7, Section 9, Section 10, Section 13, Section 14, Section 15, Section 16, Section 18, Section 19, Section 20, Section 21, Section 29, Section 30(2), Section 31, Section 31(1), Section 31(6), Section 60(6), Section 240A(1), Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016
Section 7, Section 11, Section 11(6-A), Section 16, Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996