All insights

Does simply plugging imported parts together for customers count as manufacturing a new product?

Commissioner of Central Excise vs M/s Xerox India Ltd.

The Supreme Court ruled that simply putting together pre-packaged parts of a photocopier to fit a customer's request (kitting) does not count as manufacturing a new product.

Litigation India Editorial 5 August 2026 1 min read 2024 INSC 805

Story

Key points1 / 7

Case at a Glance

  • Xerox India vs Tax Department
  • Dispute over photo-copier assembly
  • Tax claim of Rs. 17+ Crore
  • Decided by the Supreme Court
Commissioner of Central Excise vs M/s Xerox India Ltd. · 2024 INSC 8052026-08-05T18:21:43.047334+00:00
Key points2 / 7

What Happened?

  • Xerox imported printer parts safely
  • Paid custom duty as complete machines
  • Unpacked and grouped parts at warehouse
  • Tax department called this 'manufacturing'
Commissioner of Central Excise vs M/s Xerox India Ltd. · 2024 INSC 8052026-08-05T18:21:43.047334+00:00
Key points3 / 7

The Core Legal Question

  • Is putting parts together 'manufacturing'?
  • Does 'kitting' create a new product?
  • Can excise duty be levied here?
  • What qualifies legally as 'manufacture'?
Commissioner of Central Excise vs M/s Xerox India Ltd. · 2024 INSC 8052026-08-05T18:21:43.047334+00:00
Key points4 / 7

What Each Side Argued

  • Department: Unassembled parts became functional machines
  • Xerox: Only safety-packing was opened
  • Xerox: No physical assembly took warehouse
  • Department: Customization equals making new goods
Commissioner of Central Excise vs M/s Xerox India Ltd. · 2024 INSC 8052026-08-05T18:21:43.047334+00:00
Key points5 / 7

What the Court Decided

  • Simply plugging parts is not manufacturing
  • No new distinct product was created
  • Government's tax demand was rejected
  • Tribunal's decision in favor of Xerox upheld
Commissioner of Central Excise vs M/s Xerox India Ltd. · 2024 INSC 8052026-08-05T18:21:43.047334+00:00
Key points6 / 7

Why It Matters

  • Protects businesses from double taxation
  • Clarifies the definition of manufacturing
  • Stops arbitrary tax department demands
  • Requires proper evidence from tax officers
Commissioner of Central Excise vs M/s Xerox India Ltd. · 2024 INSC 8052026-08-05T18:21:43.047334+00:00
Key points7 / 7

Key Takeaway for Businesses

  • Convenience packing is not manufacturing
  • Keep clear records of custom classifications
  • Tax departments need physical verification
  • Know your rights against unfair duties
Commissioner of Central Excise vs M/s Xerox India Ltd. · 2024 INSC 8052026-08-05T18:21:43.047334+00:00
Commissioner of Central Excise vs M/s Xerox India Ltd. — infographic summary

What this case means

The Supreme Court ruled that simply putting together pre-packaged parts of a photocopier to fit a customer's request (kitting) does not count as manufacturing a new product.

What the Supreme Court held

The Supreme Court dismissed the Tax Department's appeals and ruled in favor of Xerox India. The Court held that simply unpacking and plugging parts together (kitting) does not create a new commercial product and therefore does not attract excise duty.

Case: Commissioner of Central Excise vs M/s Xerox India Ltd. (2024) Citation: 2024 INSC 805

Want the full legal reasoning, citations and case documents?

Read the full judgment analysis
Excise Duty
Definition of Manufacture
Kitting and Assembly
Customs Duty
Tax Law / Excise Duty
Supreme Court legal news
Supreme Court judgment today
latest Supreme Court news

More in Tax Law / Excise Duty