Story
No Interim Orders in Section 92 Suits Before Leave is Granted
The Supreme Court ruled that a civil court cannot pass protective interim orders in a public trust suit while the leave application under Section 92 CPC remains pending.
Civil Court Cannot Pass Interim Orders Before Section 92 Leave is Granted
The Central Legal Question
Can a civil court pass interim protective orders in a Section 92 CPC suit before granting leave to institute it?
Appellant's Argument
Court is not a mute spectator; it retains power under Section 94, Order XL Rule 1, and inherent jurisdiction under Section 151 to pass protective orders.
What is Leave Under Section 92 CPC?
A mandatory court permission required before filing a suit relating to a public charitable or religious trust; without it no suit is validly instituted.
No Interim Orders Before Leave
A civil court cannot pass protective or preservatory interim orders while a Section 92 leave application is pending.
Leave is Threshold Condition
Until leave is granted, no valid proceeding exists in which interlocutory applications can be entertained.
Section 94 and 151 Inapplicable
Supplemental proceedings and inherent powers cannot be invoked before a valid suit is instituted.
Legal Reference
| Legal Subject | Provision Applied | Equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| Leave to institute suit | Section 92, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 | — |
| Supplemental proceedings / Receiver | Section 94, Order XL Rule 1, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 | Section 503, Old Code of Civil Procedure |
| Inherent powers of court | Section 151, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 | — |
| Procedural provisions to miscellaneous proceedings | Section 141, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 | — |
What this case means
This case clarifies that a civil court cannot appoint a receiver or pass any protective or preservatory interim orders in favour of parties who have filed a suit against a public trust under Section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, while their application for leave to sue is still pending. Until the court grants leave, there is no valid proceeding before it. However, in genuinely urgent situations, a court may grant leave on an urgent ex parte basis and record its reasons in writing.
What the Supreme Court held
The Supreme Court dismissed the appeals and held that a civil court seized of a plaint under Section 92 of the Code, along with a leave application, is not empowered to pass protective or preservatory interim orders pending disposal of the leave application. However, the Court clarified that for compelling reasons to be recorded in writing, where facts disclose the necessity of urgent relief, notice prior to the grant of leave may be dispensed with, enabling ex parte grant of leave, after which the trust retains liberty to seek recall.
Case: S.PANCHALINGU & ORS. VERSUS PEOPLE’S EDUCATION TRUST (R) & OTHERS ETC. (2026) Citation: 2026 INSC 1010, SLP (C) NOs.25577-25579 of 2025
Want the full legal reasoning, citations and case documents?
Read the full judgment analysis