All insights

Can a Civil Court pass interim orders before granting leave under Section 92 CPC?

Civil Court Cannot Pass Interim Orders Before Section 92 Leave is Granted

This case clarifies that a civil court cannot appoint a receiver or pass any protective or preservatory interim orders in favour of parties who have filed a suit against a public trust under Section 9

Litigation India Editorial 18 September 2026 1 min read 2026 INSC 1010, SLP (C) NOs.25577-25579 of 2025

Story

Case at a glance1 / 7

Supreme Court of India

No Interim Orders in Section 92 Suits Before Leave is Granted

S. Panchalingu & Ors. vs. People's Education Trust (R) & Others — 2026 INSC 1010

Court: Supreme Court of IndiaDate of Decision: 18 September 2026Bench: Justice Manoj Misra and Justice ManmohanArea of Law: Civil Procedure, Public Trusts, Interim Relief, ReceiversCitation: 2026 INSC 1010, SLP (C) Nos. 25577-25579 of 2025
Civil Court Cannot Pass Interim Orders Before Section 92 Leave is Granted · 2026 INSC 1010, SLP (C) NOs.25577-25579 of 20252026-09-18T20:19:09.044630+00:00
The legal question2 / 7

Can a Civil Court pass interim protective orders in a Section 92 CPC suit before granting leave to institute it?

Arguments on Both Sides

  • Appellant: The Court is not a mute spectator; it retains power to appoint a receiver under Section 94 read with Order XL Rule 1, and under Section 151.
  • Appellant: Order XL Rule 1 omits the phrase 'in a suit,' conferring wider jurisdiction; and an application for leave is a civil proceeding to which Section 141 applies.
  • Appellant: Appointment of a receiver is protective and preservatory, not adjudicatory, and protective jurisdiction pending leave is recognised in several High Courts.
  • Respondent: No suit exists until leave is granted; supplemental proceedings under Section 94 presuppose an existing underlying proceeding.
  • Respondent: Section 151 inherent power cannot be exercised in conflict with express provisions of the Code.
  • Respondent: The phrase 'having obtained' in Section 92 makes it sui generis; Parliament deliberately did not amend Section 91 similarly.
Civil Court Cannot Pass Interim Orders Before Section 92 Leave is Granted · 2026 INSC 1010, SLP (C) NOs.25577-25579 of 20252026-09-18T20:19:09.044630+00:00
Statutory comparison3 / 7

Statutory Provisions: What They Say and How the Court Applied Them

ProvisionWhat it saysHow the Court applied it
Section 92, CPC 1908Requires leave of court as mandatory pre-condition to institute suit relating to public charitable/religious trust.Leave held to be a threshold condition; no interim orders can be passed while leave is pending.
Section 94, CPC 1908Provides for supplemental proceedings including appointment of a receiver.Rejected for pre-leave stage as it presupposes an existing underlying proceeding.
Section 151, CPC 1908Preserves inherent jurisdiction of the court.Cannot be invoked in conflict with express provisions of the Code including Section 92.
Section 141, CPC 1908Makes procedural provisions applicable to miscellaneous proceedings.Applies only to procedural rights; cannot override substantive safeguard in Section 92.
Order XL Rule 1, CPC 1908Empowers court to appoint a receiver over any property before or after decree.Phrase 'before or after decree' presupposes a validly instituted suit; inapplicable before leave.
Civil Court Cannot Pass Interim Orders Before Section 92 Leave is Granted · 2026 INSC 1010, SLP (C) NOs.25577-25579 of 20252026-09-18T20:19:09.044630+00:00
The Court's reasoning4 / 7

The Court's Reasoning: Step by Step

  1. 1Step 1: Section 92 of the Code contains the phrase 'having obtained the leave of the Court' as a mandatory pre-condition to institution of a suit; unlike other provisions requiring leave, this phrase is uniquely emphatic.
  2. 2Step 2: Leave consideration under Section 92 is a 'threshold proceeding' — until leave is granted, no valid suit is pending and no interlocutory applications can be entertained (Operation Asha, 2026; R.M. Naryana Chettiar, 1991).
  3. 3Step 3: Section 94 supplemental proceedings presuppose an existing underlying proceeding; Section 141 applies only to procedural rights and cannot override Section 92's substantive safeguard; Section 151 inherent power cannot conflict with express provisions.
  4. 4Step 4: Order XL Rule 1's phrase 'before or after decree' presupposes a validly instituted suit; appointing a receiver before leave would dislodge trust management and defeat the protective purpose of Section 92 if leave is refused.
  5. 5Step 5: Narrow exception carved out — in genuinely urgent situations, courts may grant leave ex parte with recorded prima facie reasons; trust retains liberty to seek recall of the leave order.
Civil Court Cannot Pass Interim Orders Before Section 92 Leave is Granted · 2026 INSC 1010, SLP (C) NOs.25577-25579 of 20252026-09-18T20:19:09.044630+00:00
Key points5 / 7

Key Legal Distinction: General Suits vs. Section 92 Suits

Why Section 92 suits are treated differently at the pre-leave stage

  • In ordinary civil suits, a suit is instituted upon presentation of a plaint under Section 26 and Order IV of the Code; interim relief can be sought immediately.
  • In a Section 92 suit, the phrase 'having obtained the leave of the Court' is a mandatory pre-condition; the suit is instituted only upon grant of leave, making it distinct from all other suits requiring leave.
  • Parliament deliberately chose not to amend Section 91 to include a similar 'having obtained' requirement, underscoring that Section 92 is sui generis.
  • In other proceedings requiring leave (e.g., guardian appointment under Guardians and Wards Act), courts have recognised protective jurisdiction during the pendency of the leave application — but those statutes do not contain the same emphatic pre-condition language as Section 92.
  • Appointment of a receiver in a Section 92 suit is intrusive, dislodging management of a public trust; granting such relief before leave would undermine the protective purpose of Section 92 if leave is ultimately refused.
Civil Court Cannot Pass Interim Orders Before Section 92 Leave is Granted · 2026 INSC 1010, SLP (C) NOs.25577-25579 of 20252026-09-18T20:19:09.044630+00:00
The verdict6 / 7

The Verdict

  • The Fact: The Principal District and Sessions Judge, Mandya, appointed an ad hoc committee to manage People's Education Trust while a Section 92 leave application was still pending.
  • The Law: The grant of leave under Section 92 is an essential and mandatory pre-condition; in its absence there is no pending proceeding and no power to pass protective interim orders under Sections 94, 151 or Order XL Rule 1.
  • The Result: Appeals dismissed. However, courts may in compelling and urgent situations grant leave ex parte with written reasons; the trust retains liberty to seek recall of the leave order.
Appeals dismissed. A Civil Court is not empowered to pass protective or preservatory interim orders pending disposal of the leave application under Section 92 CPC. However, for compelling reasons recorded in writing, notice prior to grant of leave may be dispensed with.
Civil Court Cannot Pass Interim Orders Before Section 92 Leave is Granted · 2026 INSC 1010, SLP (C) NOs.25577-25579 of 20252026-09-18T20:19:09.044630+00:00
Why it matters7 / 7

Why This Judgment Matters

Practical significance for public trusts, litigants and courts

  • Public charitable and religious trusts are now protected from disruptive interim management changes — such as appointment of receivers or ad hoc committees — before any suit against them is formally admitted by court.
  • Plaintiffs cannot use the mere filing of a Section 92 plaint as leverage to obtain interim control over trust property or management while their leave application is still being considered.
  • Courts across India now have clear guidance resolving the longstanding divergence of High Court opinions on this question, bringing uniformity to Section 92 proceedings.
  • The judgment's narrow urgent-relief exception ensures that genuinely urgent situations where trust property is at risk are not left without remedy — courts may grant ex parte leave with recorded reasons.
Leave under Section 92 CPC is a threshold condition: no suit, no proceeding, no interim order — until leave is granted.
Civil Court Cannot Pass Interim Orders Before Section 92 Leave is Granted · 2026 INSC 1010, SLP (C) NOs.25577-25579 of 20252026-09-18T20:19:09.044630+00:00
Litigation India Legal Explainer

No Interim Orders in Section 92 Suits Before Leave is Granted

The Supreme Court ruled that a civil court cannot pass protective interim orders in a public trust suit while the leave application under Section 92 CPC remains pending.

Civil Court Cannot Pass Interim Orders Before Section 92 Leave is Granted

The Legal Conflict

The Central Legal Question

Can a civil court pass interim protective orders in a Section 92 CPC suit before granting leave to institute it?

Appellant's Argument

Court is not a mute spectator; it retains power under Section 94, Order XL Rule 1, and inherent jurisdiction under Section 151 to pass protective orders.

What is Leave Under Section 92 CPC?

A mandatory court permission required before filing a suit relating to a public charitable or religious trust; without it no suit is validly instituted.

The Supreme Court's Verdict

No Interim Orders Before Leave

A civil court cannot pass protective or preservatory interim orders while a Section 92 leave application is pending.

Leave is Threshold Condition

Until leave is granted, no valid proceeding exists in which interlocutory applications can be entertained.

Section 94 and 151 Inapplicable

Supplemental proceedings and inherent powers cannot be invoked before a valid suit is instituted.

Legal Reference

Legal SubjectProvision AppliedEquivalent
Leave to institute suitSection 92, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908—
Supplemental proceedings / ReceiverSection 94, Order XL Rule 1, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908Section 503, Old Code of Civil Procedure
Inherent powers of courtSection 151, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908—
Procedural provisions to miscellaneous proceedingsSection 141, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908—
litigationindia.com2026 INSC 1010, SLP (C) NOs.25577-25579 of 2025 · 2026-09-18T20:19:09.044630+00:00Insight First, Action Next

What this case means

This case clarifies that a civil court cannot appoint a receiver or pass any protective or preservatory interim orders in favour of parties who have filed a suit against a public trust under Section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, while their application for leave to sue is still pending. Until the court grants leave, there is no valid proceeding before it. However, in genuinely urgent situations, a court may grant leave on an urgent ex parte basis and record its reasons in writing.

What the Supreme Court held

The Supreme Court dismissed the appeals and held that a civil court seized of a plaint under Section 92 of the Code, along with a leave application, is not empowered to pass protective or preservatory interim orders pending disposal of the leave application. However, the Court clarified that for compelling reasons to be recorded in writing, where facts disclose the necessity of urgent relief, notice prior to the grant of leave may be dispensed with, enabling ex parte grant of leave, after which the trust retains liberty to seek recall.

Case: S.PANCHALINGU & ORS. VERSUS PEOPLE’S EDUCATION TRUST (R) & OTHERS ETC. (2026) Citation: 2026 INSC 1010, SLP (C) NOs.25577-25579 of 2025

Want the full legal reasoning, citations and case documents?

Read the full judgment analysis
Section 92 CPC
Civil Court
Leave Application
Interim Orders
Protective Orders
Preservatory Orders
Receiver
Public Trust
Charitable Trust
Religious Trust
Inherent Jurisdiction
Order XL Rule 1
Section 92, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
Section 94, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908